animated goddess mdbs banner animated goddess


MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information
THE STATE OF RESEARCH
COMPLIMENTARY & ALTERNATIVE THERAPIES





RESEARCH SUBJECTS

  • Types of Clinical Trials

  • Problems With Clinical Trials

  • Why Is There So Little Research?

  • The Way Forward

  • The Placebo Response

  • Holistic Links




  • INTRODUCTION


    Although the popularity of many complimentary therapies may be widespread, it is not generally based on a broad understanding of what these therapies can offer. Complimentary medicine seems to be largely taken on trust. Given its popular status, there is a somewhat surprising and possibly troubling lack of research on the subject. To a large extent even the most basic questions remain unanswered. Which complementary therapies are effective? Are they as safe and natural as claimed? More complex issues are even more difficult to resolve. Do complementary therapies promote health or prevent illness? Could they reduce medical expenditure? Is there a "scientific basis" for their action?

    conventional research


    Much more research into complementary therapies is needed. Some conventional research methods, however, are not ideally suited to evaluating the benefits of these therapies because they do not take into account the patient's participation in the healing process.





    TYPES OF CLINICAL TRIALS


    Different types of clinical trials, originally devised to test pharmaceutical drugs and treatments in conventional medicine, are now being used to investigate complementary therapies. A controlled clinical trial compares at least two groups of patients: an experimental group that receives the treatment, and a control group that does not. This does not necessarily determine whether a procedure or medication "works", however, since any treatment, even taking a medical history, tends to have therapeutic effect. To take this into account, the placebo controlled clinical trial was devised, in which both groups are given seemingly identical treatments, but the treatment of the control group is inactive (See Placebo Response). For the treatment to be deemed to have worked, patients in the experimental group must perform significantly better than those taking the placebo. Researchers also try to include as many people as possible in the trial to balance out any personal factors, such as one patient being more ill than another, and to reduce the likelihood of therapeutic benefits being attributed to chance.

    Further risks of bias are ruled out by assigning patients at random into both groups, and the randomized controlled trial has been the gold standard in scientific research since the 1950s. Taking this one step further, the ultimate type of research trial is the "randomized double-blind" study, in which neither the patient nor the practitioner knows if the treatment is real or a placebo. The aim of this method is to ensure that nay improvement in the treated group has not been influenced by individual attitudes, such as a practitioner's strong belief in the efficacy of a treatment.

    Clinical trials are sometimes evaluated with what is known as a systematic review or meta-analysis, in which the results of a number of trials are combined. Small trials that remain inconclusive themselves may, when linked with trials that are designed better, yield more significant results. In complementary medicine, there are few possibilities for meta-analyses until more trials of therapies are available, but in the 1990s several reviews of this type did produce evidence that homeopathic treatments, acupuncture and manipulative therapies have clinical benefits.


    laboratory  research


    There is little incentive for commercial funding of research into herbal medicine due to the lack of profitable patents to acquire, since many plant remedies have been used for hundreds of years and are widely available.





    PROBLEMS WITH CLINICAL TRIALS


    The use of randomized controlled trials to investigate complementary therapies can be problematic. Critics point out that randomization neglects a patient's right to choose, and that the success of complementary therapies depends to a great degree on the knowledge, skills, and attitude of the practitioners. In many cases - particularly for mind-, body-, and movement-oriented therapies - treatment is more complex than a simple administration of pills, and it can be hard to select a "blinded" control treatment. How do you give a placebo massage, or even placebo acupuncture, not to mention placebo psychotherapy? Clinical trials also contradict the desire of many patients to participate in the healing process, a vital factor in many complementary therapies.

    The Evidence & Research cited in the therapies and diagnostic sections:

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Therapy: Touch & Movement Therapies

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Therapy: Medicinal Therapies

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Therapy: Diagnostic Techniques

    is based on the best scientific research available: the 1,500 randomized controlled trials (not all double-blind) on the database of the Research Council for Complementary Medicine in the UK, which has worked with the Office of Alternative and Complementary Medicine of the National Institutes of Health in the US. The findings suggest that some complementary therapies can be analyzed in this way and may be clinically effective, but there is a lack of research. Researchers in conventional medicine have yet to show great interest in complementary medicine, nor have complimentary practitioners had much interest in research. Much of the research so far has been by health care providers practicing complementary therapies.




    WHY IS THERE SO LITTLE RESEARCH?


    Unlike drug trials, funding for complementary medicine research is scant. Drug companies are not likely to invest, since there are few financially attractive patents to acquire; most herbal remedies, for example, have been in use for centuries. Nor do complementary practitioners wanting to carry out research have the backing of universities, hospitals, statisticians, and full-time research staff - all elements that create a research environment for conventional medicine. As complementary therapies develop their own professional bodies and academic groups, the facilities to carry out research will grow and coherent programs will develop.

    Ailments studied in conventional research may not be representative of those commonly treated by complementary medicine. Postoperative nausea, for example, has been studied because it can be easily gauged and a hospital-based researcher has access to a large number of patients, but it is not a condition for which complimentary therapies are often used. Chronic fatigue syndrome, on the other hand, is often helped by complementary medicine, but is unlikely to be treated in hospitals and cannot be quantified easily.

    It will always be difficult to make general statements about the efficacy of complementary medicine, because therapies differ so much, and because so much depends on the approach and skill of the practitioner. Even if a definite statement could be made about one therapy, it might only apply to one condition; for example, a therapy shown to be effective for irritable bowel syndrome may not be proved to work for any other ailment.

    Adapting research conclusions into practical knowledge is also far from simple. For example, a placebo controlled trial of homeopathy might find this therapy more effective than a placebo for migraines, but it fails to indicate whether homeopathy would be more effective than another approach for the same condition. There are scientifically rigorous ways of researching complementary therapies that take account of individuality and relationships, but they are often more complex than randomized controlled trials.




    THE WAY FORWARD


    It is important to not that many conventional treatments - most surgery and physiotherapy, for example - have never been subjected to clinical trials. Moreover, only a quarter of studies reported in leading medical journals are estimated to be based on randomized controlled trials. If complimentary and mainstream medicine are to integrate more closely, and new approaches are to be evaluated, thorough research is needed, and a way to apply clinical trials must be found.

    Finding a scientific explanation for the principles behind many complementary therapies is one of the most difficult issues. For example, there is no anatomical basis for the existence of acupuncture meridian, nor a biochemical explanation of how homeopathic remedies could work. Although the use of acupuncture in conventional pain management took a great leap forward when it was discovered that endorphins (a body's natural opiate, a morphine-like substance produced naturally by the body to relieve pain) could be released during treatment, this kind of research depends on high technology, and there is limited funding.

    "If the present popularity of complementary medicine is to be more than yet another passing fashion, it is essential to cultivate an atmosphere of constructive criticism, informed debate, and balanced views... those who are inspired by an attitude of constructive criticism will surely turn out to be the true champions of complementary medicine."

    By Professor Edzard Ernst of the University of Exeter; UK: Complementary Medicine: An Objective Appraisal






    THE PLACEBO RESPONSE


    A placebo (from the Latin for "I will please") is an inactive medication or treatment given to a patient in place of a genuine drug or medical technique. In clinical trials, new treatments are tested against a placebo, which may be a sugar pill or meaningless procedure. Because patients expect it to work, the placebo may have a therapeutic effect. This is in fact the self-healing response, which conventional doctors often dismiss because placebos are not an intervention. However, it is highly significant that, when given a placebo, around 30 percent or people in clinical trials feel much improvement; some researchers say this can rise to as much as 90%. The opposite also appears to be true - patients receiving insensitive treatment from practitioners often feel worse - a "nocebo" effect. How a treatment is given, by whom, and in what setting, is clearly important, but little is understood about the physical and psychological processes involved. All treatments, however, particularly surgical procedures, do have a large placebo component. Immune system research has shown how patients' expectations and feelings can influence healing processes, and the mind/body relationship in all illness, especially long-term disease, has a major effect on the outcome of health problems.





    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information: An Explanation of Holistic Medicine

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information: The Rise In Popularity

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information: Mind / Body Medicine

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information: The Future of Medicine




    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Index

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Therapy Index

    MoonDragon's Holistic Health Links Page 1

    MoonDragon's Holistic Health Links Page 2

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information




    RELATED LINKS

    MoonDragon's Nutrition Therapy: Preparing Produce for Juicing

    MoonDragon's Nutritional Recipe Index

    MoonDragon's Health & Wellness: Nutrition Basics Index

    MoonDragon's Nutritional Therapy Index

    MoonDragon's Nutritional Analysis Index

    MoonDragon's Nutritional Diet Index

    MoonDragon's Nutrition Information Index




    HERBS, OILS, & SUPPLIES

    MoonDragon's Health & Wellness: Manufacturers & Distributors

    See all our merchant banners below for products, remedies and supplements recommended on this web site.




    HELPFUL PRODUCTS & FURTHER EDUCATION

  • Prescription for Nutritional Healing: The A-To-Z Guide To Supplements
    -- by Phyllis A. Balch, James F. Balch - 2nd Edition

  • Prescription for Nutritional Healing: The A-To-Z Guide To Supplements
    -- by Phyllis A. Balch, James F. Balch - 4th Edition

  • Prescription for Herbal Healing: The A-To-Z Reference To Common Disorders
    -- by Phyllis A. Balch

  • The Complete Guide to Natural Healing



    This is only a small sample of educational materials and products available through Amazon.com. Use the search box provided below to search for a particular item.


  • If you see a suggested Amazon product "not there" as indicated by an orange box with the Amazon logo, this only means the specific product link has been changed by Amazon.com. Use the "click here" icon on the orange box and it will bring you to Amazon.com and you can do a search for a specific product using keywords and a new list of available products and prices will show. Their product and resource links are constantly changing and being upgraded. Many times there are more than one link to a specific product. Prices will vary between product distributors so it pays to shop around and do price comparisons.


    Educational materials and health products are available through Amazon.com. Use the search box provided below to search for a particular item.








    For a full list of available products from Mountain Rose Herbs, click on banner below:







    Mountain Rose Bulk Herbs



    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs A
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs B
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs C
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs D
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs E
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs F
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs G
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs H
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs I
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs J
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs K
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs L


    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs M
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs N
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs O
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs P
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs R
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs S
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs T
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs U
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs V
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs W
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Bulk Herbs Y


    Mountain Rose Aromatherapy Oils



    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils A-B
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils C-E
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils F-L
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils M-P
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils Q-Z
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils: Oil Blends & Resins
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils: Diffusers, Nebulizers, & Burners
    Mountain Rose Herbs, Aromatherapy Oils: Oil Kits

    Mountain Rose Herbs.com: Order Online

    Accessories & Tools
    Aroma Sprays & Flower Waters
    Body & Bath
    Bulk Herbs
    Bulk Ingredients
    Bulk Oils
    Butters
    Capsules
    Clays
    Essential Oils

    Facial Care
    Hair Care
    Herbal Extracts
    Herbal Oils
    Herbal Salves & Balms
    Herbal Teas
    Herbs For Pets
    Incense, Resins & Candles
    Massage Oils
    Medicinal Herb Seeds
    Tea Brewing Supplies




    Starwest Botanicals




    HerbsPro Supplement Store

    HerbsPro

    Learn more about Native Remedies

    Learn about PetAlive natural remedies for pets!





    Mountain Rose Herbs. A Herbs, Health and Harmony Company. Since 1987


    Kalyx.com Herbs, Foods, Supplements, Bath & Body


    House of Nutrition Online


    Chinese Herbs Direct

    Ayurvedic Herbs Direct

    Pet Herbs Direct

    Pharmapacks.com

    TakeHerb.com

    Aloe Elite - Irritable Bowel, Crohn's Disease, Ulcerative Colitis

    Wild Divine - Stress relief training software and meditation.

    Aleva Health - Hosiery, Orthopedics, Wound Care, Support, Diabetic Socks

    Santosha Shop - Yoga Meditation Santosha Shop - Yoga Meditation








    MoonDragon's Nutrition Information Index

    MoonDragon's Health & Wellness: Nutrition Basics Index

    MoonDragon's Health & Wellness: Therapy Index

    MoonDragon's Nutrition Therapy Index

    MoonDragon's Alternative Health Information Index

    MoonDragon's Aromatherapy Information Index

    MoonDragon's Health & Wellness Index

    MoonDragon's ObGyn Womens Health Information Index by Subject Order

    MoonDragon's ObGyn Womens Health Information Index by Alphabetical Order

    MoonDragon's Main Indexlisting

    MoonDragon's Home Page




    MOONDRAGON'S REALM - WEBSITE DIRECTORY


    A website map to help you find what you are looking for on MoonDragon.org's Website. Available pages have been listed under appropriate directory headings.